Trade-In Program

At Starke Trading Company, we make it easy to turn your trading card collection into cash or credit. Whether you’re looking to sell high-value singles or unload bulk cards, we guarantee the best trade-in rates in Casa Grande.

Picture background

💰 Our Trade-In Rates

  • High-Value Singles
    • 50% of TCGPlayer market value in cash
    • 60% of TCGPlayer market value in trade-in credit
    • How it works: Please create a list of your singles in the TCGPlayer app and share it with us in advance so we can provide an accurate quote.
  • Bulk Cards
    • $10 per 1,000 cards
    • Energy cards are excluded from bulk pricing.

⚠️ Important Notes

  • We do have monthly limits on how much we can purchase. Please contact us in advance for large collections.
  • Rates are guaranteed at the time of trade-in, based on current TCGPlayer market prices and condition.

🚗 Collection Pick-Up Service

We know transporting large collections isn’t always easy. That’s why we’ll coordinate picking up your collection directly from you. Whether it’s a small binder or thousands of bulk cards, we’ll work with you to arrange a convenient time and location for pick-up.

⚙️ New Service: Magic Sorter

Want your collection organized before you trade it in? Our Magic Sorter can:

  • Sort Pokemon, Magic, One Piece, Lorcana, Digimon, and YuGiOh
  • Sort by color, set, type, or alphabetically
  • Sort by current market value

Pricing: $15 per up to 3,000 cards

  • Bonus: We’ll waive the fee if you trade in at least $15 in cards (market value) from the same batch.

THE MACHINE BEHIND THE MAGIC

🚀 Why Trade With Us?

  • Guaranteed best local rates
  • Cash or trade-in credit options
  • Simple, transparent process
  • Convenient sorting service for large collections

👉 Ready to get started? Contact us today to schedule your trade-in or sorter service.